When All Bets Are Off

I recently had an altercation on the avenue with an elderly woman’s personal attendant.

Standing on the corner checking my phone, when I looked up two women were coming directly toward me.

The older one was in a wheel chair clearly distressed while the young girl pushing her was on her phone blatantly ignoring the woman’s needs.

Okay, before I tell you what you already know, I do try very hard to mind my own business. I’ve learned to quell that Joan of Arc streak in me since more often than not it gets me into hot water, like the time I opened the back of a van taking dogs to the City Pound. I was very young when that happened but my passion to save all things had to be, how should I say, seriously curbed.

However, there are exceptions to my rule of not getting enmeshed in something that has nothing to do with me, like today.

It bothered me that she was treating this lady with so little regard. Granted, she was old and might have been the biggest bitch on wheels, no pun intended, but it doesn’t make it okay, at least not in my book.

I did pause, attempting to respond as opposed to reacting, but the girl on the phone really ticked me off.

“Excuse me,” I said in the nicest tone I could feign, “I think she may need your help.” The woman had grabbed my hand making me realize perhaps she suffered from dementia. She had that frightened, vacant look in her eyes that I’ve seen so often before that can only be described as terror mixed with confusion.

The girl put her hand over her phone and said, “She’s fine. It’s just what she does.”

I’m sorry, Joan was awakened on that note climbing quickly onto her steed.

“Young lady (she was in her mid 20s) I’d like you to please get off your phone. She looked at me like I was out of my mind but I held my ground.

She hung up screaming saying it was none of my business.

“I just made it my business,” I said, in that quiet Anthony Perkins/Psycho voice I’ve so sweetly mastered.

I’ve learned one thing, if someone goes off the rails you need to stay on. They quickly dig their own hole while you watch them, little by little, fall in it head first. Might I add you’re slightly pleased when they do.

The interesting part was that the old women stopped yelling. She became totally calm as though she knew somehow she was no longer completely alone. Trust me when I say it would have broken your heart in two and then some.

This is where I know I’ve matured behaviorally because I took that high road that, let’s face it, is very time consuming.

I wanted to grab this dense, clueless girl by her Gap lapels and slam her up against a wall, but I didn’t.

Instead I said, “You know, I realize our friend here is probably a handful but that’s why she needs help. She started to interrupt me. “Let me finish please. One day we may be in the same boat depending on someone’s patience to get us through. I’m asking you to please find it in your heart to be kinder to her.”

She was so young and obviously ill equipped for this type of work. My self-righteousness, alright I’ll admit it, deflated her sass like a hot-air balloon.

“I’m sure you’re a very nice girl (big lie number 1) so please try a little harder, okay?”

I knelt down and asked the woman, now docile as a lamb, her name.

She looked at me sweetly but didn’t answer.

“Her name’s Margaret,” said Cruella (couldn’t resist).

“Is there something I could do for you Margaret?” She kept looking through me as if I were a full-length hall mirror. I noticed her sweater had what looked like a soup stain along with pearls that needed a good shine.

“What’s your name?” she suddenly said in a weak Waspy voice.

“Susannah, my name is Susannah, you know, like the song.”

“Oh Susanna?” she said smiling.

“Yes that’s right.”

I then looked at the young girl and said that I was sorry (big lie number 2) if I had upset her and hoped that she’d have a better afternoon (grand slam of lies).

Of course as I walked up the street I predictably began to cry because the woman called out..

“Bye Susannah, and don’t you cry for me.” (tell me that’s not poignantly odd)

You know folks, this is my truth:

When it comes to someone or something that can’t defend itself I rarely walk away.

I don’t readily discuss this but, when I was little and my mother drank too much she’d beat me senseless. She was sick and didn’t mean it however, no one ever came to my rescue; not my dad or grandparents, nor a caring neighbor. The following morning, despite evidence to the contrary, it was as though it never happened

…but it did.

If a situation involves abusing a kid, an animal or the elderly, all bets are off.

To be quite honest, it’s a quality that I rather like in myself.

I took a personal, painful event recycling it into steady, quiet compassion.

No one’s more surprised by that than me.

Wish I could do that with every hurt and slight that comes my way but …

a forever work in progress this thingirl be.


About Susannah Bianchi

I'm just a girl who likes to write slightly on slant. I've had a career in fashion, dabbled in film and to be honest, I don't like talking about myself. Now my posts are another matter so I will let them speak for themselves. My eBooks, A New York Diary, Model Behavior: Friends For Life and Notes From A Working Cat can be found on Amazon.com. Thanks.
This entry was posted in animals, Family, friendship, Health, humor, Love, New York City, parents, Uncategorized, women and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

26 Responses to When All Bets Are Off

  1. Rob says:

    Another wonderful tale Susannah, many thanks for sharing. Stephen Foster is smiling, somewhere!
    Interesting that you invoke the battered child syndrome. Some offer it as a reason (excuse?) for battering their own kids, others, like you and Maeve, for fighting the good fight. I think it’s a weird mechanism.
    Please do be careful though: someday, someone will seriously slap you for being right.


    • Well, I’d slap them right back regretting it later no doubt. I have found when someone isn’t treated well when they’re young one of two things happen. They either become kind like your wife and myself, or they turn into shrews of the highest order. I’ve seen it. Thanks for your comments. I always appreciate them.


  2. Oh Susannah this really touches my heart. “Be kind to unkind people, they need it most.” I hope that girl learns from this encounter. I see aides everyday who are so uncaring. They come to our office to read the People magazine and click their gum…please. You could never have that job. Lord knows you would be on the news for running an unauthorized animal shelter/nursing home from your apartment..as would I. So do what you do best….bring awareness to those who need it most…you are helping more than you might know.
    I am sorry for your tragic beginnings, but glad it made you the person you have grown to be.


    • See how well you write? That was a mini essay right there. Yes, my heart has gotten me into trouble on many an occasion. That’s not to say I don’t have my meaner moments because I do. I’m just aware of what goes on around me, a bit of an albatross if you must know. Thanks for reading, always.


  3. Joan Blake says:

    HURRAY for the thingirl who observes and cares and does not look the other way. The world needs more of you.


  4. rachel bar says:

    Indifference is the disease of humans. You are the healthy one. As you know, I’ve been reading your blogs for a while, enjoy the humor and the sadness, but this one made me love the person that you are, Prada and all!


    • When I wrote it I hesitated adding that little bit of personal lore. I’ve heard it said we are as sick as our secrets so I let it stand. It was more the story of the old woman who needed someone to stand up for her. Hope I didn’t make it worse. Thanks for what you wrote. I’ve also enjoyed your last two posts – the one on Yom Kippur and your most recent.


  5. manty67 says:

    Brilliant as usual, just a shame that old lady had to suffer 😦


    • Yeah, it’s frightening when you think about it. There should be a built in sense of morality to just act accordingly and do the right thing…I’m dreaming, you do know that.


      • manty67 says:

        yeah, I like to dream like that πŸ™‚ – We can only hope that one day things will come right, but as long as everyone does their bit, we may have a chance πŸ™‚


  6. D. D. Syrdal says:

    You are my hero. Seriously, what you did was fantastic. I’m so sorry to learn of your own abuse as a child. Nothing makes me sicker than seeing children abused (and animals). There is a time to mind your own business, and a time to come to the aid of a fellow human being. I say Bravo! Well done.


    • So didn’t want it to be about me. It was just another New York story that wanted to come out. There are so many since neighborhood alone has a wealth of material. Some of the stuff I see is pretty amazing. It’s like another planet with its own particular species. I did feel terrible for that lady. The helplessness, the indifference toward her. Anyway, thanks for singling me out, it’s very noted and appreciated.


  7. backonmyown says:

    I have no doubt that you made an important connection with Margaret. This is a powerful story. Thanks for telling it.


  8. Isn’t it sad that more screening is required to buy a house or adopt a dog than is necessary to care for the vulnerable? Great story.


  9. You are a wonderful human being.

    I enjoy so much reading about your adventures with strangers! Only wish i had more time to read them all


  10. Pingback: A Stella(r) day! | Back On My Own

  11. backonmyown says:

    Hi Susannah. I mentioned your name and linked to this post on my latest post. I should have asked you if it was okay, but I didn’t think you’d mind. Tell me if I’m wrong and I’ll remove it immediately. Thanks.


  12. merryprangster says:



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.